{"audit_id":"e2b77c8a-c3f6-4c24-98ca-9c9aba6b4903","tx_id":"reportcheck-e2b77c8a-c3f6-4c24-98ca-9c9aba6b4903","tx_hash":null,"report_type":"API_510","findings":[{"claim_id":"c1","code":"API 510","section":"5.4.1","cited_paragraph_text":"The maximum allowable working pressure shall not exceed the nameplate rating established by the original manufacturer's data report and ASME Section VIII code calculations.","expected_paragraph_text":"The maximum allowable working pressure shall not exceed the nameplate rating of the pressure vessel as established by the original manufacturer's data report and Code calculations per ASME Section VIII.","jaccard_score":0.944,"error_type":"unit_mismatch","severity":"high","detail":"Report uses unit \"BAR\" but canonical section 5.4.1 expects one of: PSI, PSIG, kPa, MPa."},{"claim_id":"c2","code":"API 510","section":"5.5.2","cited_paragraph_text":"The minimum required thickness for continued service shall be calculated using the cylindrical shell formula with internal pressure, inside radius, allowable stress, and joint efficiency.","expected_paragraph_text":"The minimum required thickness for continued service shall be calculated using the formula tmin equals P times R divided by S times E minus 0.6 P for cylindrical shells under internal pressure, where P is the maximum allowable working pressure, R is inside radius, S is allowable stress, and E is joint efficiency.","jaccard_score":0.607,"error_type":null,"severity":null,"detail":null},{"claim_id":"c3","code":"API 510","section":"6.3","cited_paragraph_text":"External visual inspection of pressure vessels in service shall occur at intervals not exceeding five years or one fourth of the calculated remaining life, whichever is shorter.","expected_paragraph_text":"Pressure vessels in service shall receive an external visual inspection at intervals not exceeding 5 years or one fourth of the calculated remaining life of the vessel, whichever is shorter.","jaccard_score":0.8,"error_type":null,"severity":null,"detail":null},{"claim_id":"c4","code":"API 510","section":"6.5","cited_paragraph_text":"The interval between internal inspections shall not exceed one half the calculated remaining life of the vessel or ten years, whichever is less, unless on stream inspection is substituted.","expected_paragraph_text":"The interval between internal inspections shall not exceed one half the calculated remaining life of the vessel or 10 years, whichever is less, unless on stream inspection is substituted per Section 6.4.","jaccard_score":0.895,"error_type":null,"severity":null,"detail":null},{"claim_id":"c5","code":"API 510","section":"7.1.1","cited_paragraph_text":"The long term corrosion rate is calculated by subtracting actual thickness measured at the most recent inspection from actual thickness measured at the initial installation and dividing by the time interval between measurements.","expected_paragraph_text":"The long term corrosion rate shall be calculated by subtracting the actual thickness measured at the most recent inspection from the actual thickness measured at the initial installation and dividing by the time interval between the two measurements.","jaccard_score":0.95,"error_type":null,"severity":null,"detail":null},{"claim_id":"c6","code":"API 510","section":"7.2","cited_paragraph_text":"Remaining life of the pressure vessel shall be calculated by subtracting minimum required thickness from actual thickness and dividing by the corrosion rate.","expected_paragraph_text":"The remaining life of the pressure vessel shall be calculated by subtracting the minimum required thickness from the actual thickness and dividing by the corrosion rate.","jaccard_score":1,"error_type":null,"severity":null,"detail":null},{"claim_id":"c7","code":"API 510","section":"8.1.3","cited_paragraph_text":"Garden tomatoes require full sun exposure of at least six hours daily and benefit from companion planting with basil to deter common pest insects during the summer growing season.","expected_paragraph_text":"All repairs and alterations to pressure vessels shall be performed by an organization holding a valid National Board R Certificate of Authorization or equivalent jurisdictional authorization in accordance with the National Board Inspection Code NBIC.","jaccard_score":0,"error_type":"wrong_paragraph","severity":"high","detail":"Claim text overlap with canonical paragraph is 0 (threshold 0.15). The report cited API 510 8.1.3 but the prose does not match the canonical content."},{"claim_id":"c8","code":"API 510","section":"5.4.2","cited_paragraph_text":"Pressure relief devices shall be inspected, tested, and maintained per API 576 and set at or below the maximum allowable working pressure.","expected_paragraph_text":"Pressure relief devices protecting pressure vessels shall be inspected, tested, and maintained at intervals consistent with the requirements of API 576 and shall be set at or below the maximum allowable working pressure.","jaccard_score":0.722,"error_type":null,"severity":null,"detail":null},{"claim_id":"c9","code":"API 510","section":"6.4","cited_paragraph_text":"On stream inspection methods including ultrasonic thickness measurement, radiography, and acoustic emission may be substituted for internal inspection per Section 6.4.","expected_paragraph_text":"On stream inspection methods including ultrasonic thickness measurement, radiography, and acoustic emission may be substituted for internal inspection provided the methods meet the requirements of API 510 Section 6.4 and the owner user's inspection plan.","jaccard_score":0.6,"error_type":null,"severity":null,"detail":null},{"claim_id":"c10","code":"API 510","section":"5.6","cited_paragraph_text":"The owner shall maintain accounting records showing total annual revenue, payroll expenses, capital expenditures, and depreciation schedules for tax filing purposes.","expected_paragraph_text":"Pressure vessel components that do not meet the minimum required thickness or that contain damage exceeding inspection acceptance criteria shall be evaluated for fitness for service in accordance with API 579-1 ASME FFS-1.","jaccard_score":0,"error_type":"wrong_paragraph","severity":"high","detail":"Claim text overlap with canonical paragraph is 0 (threshold 0.15). The report cited API 510 5.6 but the prose does not match the canonical content."},{"claim_id":"c11","code":"API 510","section":"9.4","cited_paragraph_text":"Inspectors shall complete a minimum of eight hours of continuing professional development annually to maintain the API 510 certification.","expected_paragraph_text":"Inspectors shall complete a minimum of 8 hours of continuing professional development annually relevant to API 510 and pressure vessel inspection to maintain certification.","jaccard_score":0.706,"error_type":null,"severity":null,"detail":null},{"claim_id":"c12","code":"API 510","section":"99.99.99","cited_paragraph_text":"Coffee brewing temperature ranges between 195 and 205 degrees Fahrenheit produce optimal extraction of soluble compounds from medium roasted Arabica beans.","expected_paragraph_text":null,"jaccard_score":null,"error_type":"missing_citation","severity":"high","detail":"Code/section API 510 99.99.99 not found in canonical citation index (rule engine has 12 sections for API_510)."}],"citations_checked":12,"hallucinations_detected":[{"claim_id":"c7","code":"API 510","section":"8.1.3","reason":"Claim text overlap with canonical paragraph is 0 (threshold 0.15). The report cited API 510 8.1.3 but the prose does not match the canonical content."},{"claim_id":"c10","code":"API 510","section":"5.6","reason":"Claim text overlap with canonical paragraph is 0 (threshold 0.15). The report cited API 510 5.6 but the prose does not match the canonical content."},{"claim_id":"c12","code":"API 510","section":"99.99.99","reason":"Code/section API 510 99.99.99 not found in canonical citation index (rule engine has 12 sections for API_510)."}],"unit_errors":[{"claim_id":"c1","code":"API 510","section":"5.4.1","detail":"Report uses unit \"BAR\" but canonical section 5.4.1 expects one of: PSI, PSIG, kPa, MPa."}],"paragraph_mismatches":[{"claim_id":"c7","code":"API 510","section":"8.1.3","cited_paragraph_text":"Garden tomatoes require full sun exposure of at least six hours daily and benefit from companion planting with basil to deter common pest insects during the summer growing season.","expected_paragraph_text":"All repairs and alterations to pressure vessels shall be performed by an organization holding a valid National Board R Certificate of Authorization or equivalent jurisdictional authorization in accordance with the National Board Inspection Code NBIC.","jaccard_score":0},{"claim_id":"c10","code":"API 510","section":"5.6","cited_paragraph_text":"The owner shall maintain accounting records showing total annual revenue, payroll expenses, capital expenditures, and depreciation schedules for tax filing purposes.","expected_paragraph_text":"Pressure vessel components that do not meet the minimum required thickness or that contain damage exceeding inspection acceptance criteria shall be evaluated for fitness for service in accordance with API 579-1 ASME FFS-1.","jaccard_score":0}],"confidence_score":67,"rule_engine_version":"1.0.0","deterministic":true,"llm_used":false,"privacy":{"mode":"NIM_ONLY","retention_seconds":60,"report_text_persisted":false,"external_llm_used":false}}